The Canadian DMCA Video Competition
Jim Prentice refusing to answer questions, just keeps shouting
Canadian Industry Minister lies about his Canadian DMCA on national radio, then hangs up
CBC Radio's Search Engine just posted/aired its interview with Canadian
Industry Minister Jim Prentice about his Canadian version of the
Digital Millennium Copyright Act. They've been trying to get him on the
air for months now and he finally consented to ten minutes, but he
delivered nothing but spin and outright lies about his legislation and
ended up hanging up on Jesse Brown, the interviewer.
You have to listen to this -- in it, the Minister lies, dodges,
weaves and ducks around plain, simple questions like, "If the guy at my
corner shop unlocks my phone, is he breaking the law?" and "If my
grandfather breaks the DRM on his jazz CDs to put them on his iPod,
does that break the law?" and the biggie, "All the 'freedoms' your law
guarantees us can be overriden by DRM, right?" (Prentice's answer to
this last one, "The market will take care of it," is absolutely
priceless.)
Copyright cock-up
On the surface of it, Jim Prentice's Bill C-61 spells out a number of
consumer-friendly provisions like time-shifting, format-shifting and
exceptions for personal use. But each one has an asterisk attached:
users will be forbidden from breaking technological locks – sometimes
called Digital Rights Management, or DRM – to access content.
This has the funny effect of making it kind of irrelevant how strong a
digital lock is. The fact that the lock on an iTunes song is fairly
easy to circumvent wouldn't matter, because now that lock would have
the force of law behind it. Nor would it matter whether your intended
use of the material is fair game, even under Canada's woefully
ill-defined “fair dealing” provisions.
Copywrong Protection
Imagine if the federal government passed a law that would make nearly
half of all Canadians criminals. Imagine if your Internet Service
Provider was obliged to report any customers who up/download more than
20MB per day. Imagine if Canada’s laws were written to protect US
corporations rather than Canadian citizens.
Canadian DMCA is worse than the American one
Canadian Industry Minister Jim Prentice introduced his answer to the
American Digital Millennium Copyright Act today as planned, and it's
even worse
than the US DMCA. The Canadian DMCA allows every single exception to
copyright to be eliminated by adding DRM: whatever the law allows you
to do, a corporation can take away, just by using DRM to prevent you
from doing it. Breaking DRM is illegal, unless you fit into a tiny,
narrow, useless exception for security research.
It used to be that Parliament got to write copyright law. Now, it's
Hollywood companies, who get to overrule Parliamentary law with
whatever "business rules" they put in their DRM.
This draconian american style dmca needs to be stopped!
The Honourable Jim Prentice, Minister of Industry, and the Honourable
Josée Verner, Minister of Canadian Heritage, Status of Women and
Official Languages, and Minister for La Francophonie, will deliver
brief statements and answer media inquiries shortly after the tabling
of a bill to amend the Copyright Act. Members of the media will
also be able to attend a technical briefing and lock-up prior to the
tabling of the bill to amend the Copyright Act.
Find ways you can help stop this here from previous posts.

